|
|
Post by wes on Dec 2, 2006 10:51:57 GMT -4
This discussion is going on right now on my board. I want to know what you guys think.
What do you think would be the outcome in Star Wars IF Obi-Wan, not Master Jinn, died at the hands of Darth Maul? I mean do you think Jinn would be able to train Anakin the right way. Would he have turned to the dark side? I mean he still brought balance to the force by throwing Sidious down the shaft, but do you think the would still stay on the light side and destroyed the Sith as a Jedi master?
I just want to know what you think.
|
|
|
|
Post by Force_Flow on Dec 2, 2006 10:54:43 GMT -4
I've actually been thinking about that a lot, lately, writing fics about it. Of course, I'd want both of 'em to live, but y'know writers…
I think Qui-Gon may train Anakin, and probably make it so Anakin wouldn't fall. Qui-Gon has that effect of people. Obi-Wan was new to the whole teaching job.
|
|
darthnotrevan
Commander
[M:0]
Your official House: M.D./ KotOR nut [H:2]
Posts: 346
|
Post by darthnotrevan on Feb 11, 2007 14:54:45 GMT -4
I guess that's an interesting point of view. IMO Anakins destiny was set down the path to the Dark Side. just thinking about this makes me wonder what would happen to the other characters, even after the prequels. ex. Would Luke and Leia come together or would she still go with Han?
I could rant forever, but that's my two cents.
|
|
noneko
Recruit
[M:2000]
[H:3]
Posts: 49
|
Post by noneko on Feb 15, 2007 19:00:14 GMT -4
I guess that's an interesting point of view. IMO Anakins destiny was set down the path to the Dark Side. just thinking about this makes me wonder what would happen to the other characters, even after the prequels. ex. Would Luke and Leia come together or would she still go with Han? I could rant forever, but that's my two cents. I think a more important thing to think about would be whether Luke and Leia would have even been born. Would Anakin have broken the Jedi code and fallen in love with Padme, or would he have remained true to the "no attachments" way of life? Also, ick. Incest is no good. They wouldn't "come together"... ick. |
|
|
|
Post by frosty on Feb 16, 2007 18:43:17 GMT -4
Well Master Jinn was old, and he'd be 10 years older during the clone wars than he was during the duel with Maul. Would he have survived the Clone wars? And then again would Master Jinn join count Dooku like Dooku said he would?
|
|
|
|
Post by Force_Flow on Jul 18, 2007 15:30:00 GMT -4
Jinn had around three apprentices: one unnamed, Xanatos, and Obi-Wan. Xanatos fell to the Dark Side on Telos during his Trial, and drew his lightsaber on Qui-Gon after Qui-Gon killed his father. I don't know if Anakin would fall or not, really. In my POV, he'd probably still get together with Padmé, but I don't know what would happen, really. Qui-Gon probably wouldn't join Dooku.
That's my view on it, anyway.
|
|
|
|
Post by hk47fan on Jul 21, 2007 19:42:58 GMT -4
FF, I agree.
I think Anakin always had a crush or feelings for Padme Qui-Gon or no Qui-Gon. The relationship was hinted at a few times in the movie, even. The relationship would most likely happen.
Somehow, I feel Anakin would have still fallen. Qui-Gon was a wise Jedi Knight and all, but honestly I always got the feeling he might have been over-confident about Anakin. Yes, Anakin did eventually restore balance(because he was the one who killed Palpatine in the end, after all, and redeemed), but Qui-Gon had alot of faith in him. Mabye in the end it was rightful faith, but I still feel probably due to his love for Padme Anakin would have fallen. He was as close to Obi-Wan as he was Qui-Gon, I think. If not closer.
It wasn't really how anyone taught him, I think. It was his how he was and his love for Padme that brought him down, pretty much.
|
|
