Trilogy or Prequels?

[Force_Flow]

I chose the Prequels. I love Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan, and the actors for Padmé and Anakin were the best. The graphics were a lot better, though they'll probably be scrap in ten years, huh?

[Ambika]

The trilogy is amazing. It's my favourite, especially The Empire Strike Back. I also like the Han and Leia relationship too much.

[Force_Flow]

I think that Padmé and Anakin had some crappy love lines, but the story was good. SW ep. 1 was the first one I ever saw, so I guess I'm a bit attached.

[Ambika]

True but Episode 1 has a good storyline. Even though Episode 3 storyline is far better in my opinion.

[Force_Flow]

They just needed to work on the dialogue between Padme and Anakin, though. Episode 3 started with the concept artists. George Lucas wanted them to make a picture of Padmé kneeling in pain as a vision to Yoda, but he couldn't help her. And there was another one where they tried to make a samurai-like Grievous.

[hk47fan]

I think I read on Wookiepedia or somewhere that George Lucas has been known to write weak dialogue, and he has written the movies.

Padme and Anakin relationship I liked a whole lot, but they should have had better dialogue yes. Someone needs to write a book just about their relationship, unless there is one out there I don't know about.

Prequels were all good, but I think Episode II was the worst. It was ok, but could have been way better. I think the whole Anakin/Padme dialogue problem factors in to that majorly.

The original trilogy is the best, in my opinion. Mabye it is just because I saw that first but still I think it has something the prequels don't. Like Ambika I loved the Han and Leia relationship. But some things from the prequels kind of messed up the OT. Such as how did Leia remember her real mother when Padme only had enough time to name her before she spoke her last words to Obi-Wan and then died.

Yet other things have been explained through EU. Such as why the Stormtroopers sounded different, and I think that was because after the Kaminoans tried to make clones against the Empire, Palpatine wanted a new host.

But even with the minor messing up in the OT here and there, I still think it is the best. But the Leia remembering her real mother always bugged me, unless since she is strong in the Force she could feel Padme's sadness inside her stomach and somehow remember that.

[Jake]

I like the trilogy better because it has Luke in it and it's very awesome when he gets the black suit and green lightsaber.

[Revan Jast]

I'd have to say the Prequels as well. Indeed, the Anakin/Padme relationship did bad in the dialouge area, but the Episode 3 final battle was to awesome. That wins for me.

[noneko]

Oh gawd trilogy by far. Episode IV is the best of them all (and the only one not directed by George Lucas, imagine that. ). I could not stand the prequels. All the "emotional scenes" just made me giggle. When I saw Episode III, the entire theater burst out laughing when Padme died, because it was just that bad. He had one of the better actresses in Hollywood right there, and he gave her one of the worst scenes ever written. Even she couldn't save that.

Of course, that's only my opinion, and all. But really, the Trilogy is the best, IMO, because it wasn't cliche, it created the stuff that now seems cliche. And again, Empire Strikes Back was awesome. Han/Leia forever. >.>

[Force_Flow]

Han/Leia forever.

I really like that relationship the best after Padmé and Anakin. And after that Luke and Mara.